Two CNC suppliers quote the same part. One says $47 per unit, the other says $62. Which is actually cheaper? It depends entirely on what's in (or left out of) each line. This guide walks through every line item on a typical CNC quote — what it means, what it hides, and how to compare apples to apples when a cheaper quote is really the more expensive one.
A proper CNC quote — the kind that avoids surprises — should contain these 10 lines. If any are missing, ask before signing the PO:
| # | Line item | Typical label variations |
|---|---|---|
| 01 | Unit price at quantity break | "Unit price", "Part price", "Each" |
| 02 | Minimum order quantity (MOQ) | "MOQ", "Min qty", "Minimum batch" |
| 03 | Setup or NRE charge (first article) | "Setup", "NRE", "Engineering", "Prep" |
| 04 | Tooling or fixture cost (if any) | "Tooling", "Fixture", "Jig cost" |
| 05 | Material grade & certification | "Material", "MTR", "Certification" |
| 06 | Finish/surface treatment | "Finish", "Treatment", "Anodize/plate/etc." |
| 07 | Inspection & documentation | "Inspection", "FAI", "QC reports" |
| 08 | Packaging spec | "Packaging", "Bulk/Indiv.", "Labeling" |
| 09 | Lead time (prototype and production) | "Lead time", "Delivery", "ETA" |
| 10 | Incoterm and shipping cost | "Incoterm", "Freight", "EXW/FOB/DDP" |
The unit price is never a single number. It's a function of quantity. A good quote shows price breaks:
| Quantity | Unit price | Total |
|---|---|---|
| 1–10 | $47.50 | $475 |
| 11–50 | $38.20 | $1,910 |
| 51–200 | $29.80 | $5,960 |
| 201–1,000 | $24.10 | $24,100 |
The unit price typically drops 20–50% from prototype quantity to production — reflecting amortized setup time and batch efficiency.
Red flags:
MOQ in CNC is different from MOQ in injection molding or castings. CNC has no tooling, so MOQ isn't about amortizing a mold. It's about the supplier's minimum economically viable batch.
Typical CNC MOQs:
If a quote says "MOQ: 500" and you need 50, it doesn't mean the supplier won't make them — it means they'll charge a setup premium. Ask for the MOQ-waived price at your actual quantity.
Instead of "can you waive MOQ?", ask "what's the unit price at my target quantity of 30?" — you'll get a direct number instead of a negotiation dance.
Non-recurring engineering (NRE) and setup charges cover:
Typical NRE for CNC parts:
| Part complexity | Typical NRE |
|---|---|
| Simple milled bracket | $50–$150 |
| Complex 5-axis part | $300–$800 |
| Swiss-machined precision part | $400–$1,200 |
| EDM-requiring features (multi-setup) | $500–$1,500 |
If NRE is hidden: some suppliers bury NRE in the unit price instead of listing it separately. At low quantities, the unit price looks high; at high quantities, it looks suspiciously cheap. Ask explicitly: "If I order this same part again in 6 months with no changes, what's the re-run price?" That price is the true marginal unit price minus NRE amortization.
CNC rarely needs dedicated tooling (that's what separates it from injection molding or stamping). But custom fixtures are sometimes required — especially for:
Typical fixture cost: $150–$1,200 depending on complexity. Usually one-time, amortized across first production run.
What to ask: Is this fixture specifically for my part, or does it become my property? If I reorder, is the fixture reused at no extra cost? Reputable shops say yes — the fixture is yours for future production.
"6061-T6 aluminum" isn't enough on its own. A complete material line includes:
Cheap quotes sometimes cut corners on material. A "6061-T6" part made from unknown-origin Chinese stock is usually functionally equivalent to US-mill 6061-T6 for most applications — but for aerospace, medical, or specification-sensitive work, the origin matters and should be explicit on the quote.
Some shops substitute 6063-T6 (extrusion grade, 75% of 6061's strength) when bar stock 6061 isn't in house. The parts look identical. A clean quote spells out the grade and the form (bar vs plate vs extrusion).
"Anodize black" is vague. Real finish specs include:
A vague quote — "parts to be anodized black" — leaves room for the cheapest-possible Type II anodize, no masking, no seal. For appearance parts or sealed functional surfaces, insist on specifics.
Common finish costs (as % of base part price):
| Finish | Added cost |
|---|---|
| Bead blast only | +5–10% |
| Type II anodize (clear or black) | +15–25% |
| Type II anodize (custom color) | +25–40% |
| Type III hard anodize | +30–50% |
| Nickel plating (electroless) | +40–60% |
| Passivation (stainless) | +5–10% |
| Powder coat (RAL color) | +15–25% |
| Chrome plating (decorative) | +50–100% |
Most quotes include basic in-process inspection (not documented). Enhanced documentation is extra:
| Inspection level | What's included | Typical cost |
|---|---|---|
| Standard (included) | In-process check, visual, basic caliper measurements | Baseline |
| First Article Inspection (FAI) | CMM-measured first part, dimensional report vs drawing | +$80–$300 per PO |
| AS9102 FAI package (aerospace) | Form 1, 2, 3 per drawing standard; full traceability | +$200–$600 per PO |
| PPAP Level 3 (automotive) | Full PPAP submission, IATF 16949-compliant | +$400–$1,500 per PO |
| Per-lot inspection certificates | Sample-rate measurement with statistical report | +$50–$150 per lot |
| 100% measured on critical features | Every part measured, not sampled | +$0.50–$3 per part |
If your drawing has ±0.02 mm callouts with no inspection spec, the supplier will assume statistical sampling. Explicitly request 100% measurement if every part must hit tolerance.
Default packaging is "bulk in poly bags, boxed". That's fine for hardware. For anything else, specify:
For medical or regulated parts, packaging is often part of the validated process — specify exactly, including which boxes go into which outer shipper.
A complete quote gives two lead times:
"Lead time: 3 weeks" without qualification is ambiguous. Does that include FAI approval wait? Does it start from PO or from approved drawing? Does it include shipping?
A clean answer looks like: "Prototype: 10 business days from PO. Production: 15 business days from FAI approval. Excludes shipping transit."
Most suppliers offer expedited production for 15–50% price premium. Usually 3–5 days faster on prototype, 5–10 on production. If your project is time-critical, ask the expedite rate when first quoting — it's a useful data point even if you don't use it.
The Incoterm determines where the price quote ends. Four common levels in CNC export:
| Incoterm | Supplier pays | Buyer pays | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| EXW (Ex Works) | Nothing beyond manufacturing | Pickup, export, ocean, import, duties, last mile | Savvy buyers with own freight forwarder |
| FOB (Free on Board) | Export clearance, dock-side handling | Ocean freight, import, duties, last mile | Buyers with own customs broker |
| DAP (Delivered at Place) | Ocean + last mile delivery | Import duties, VAT | Buyers OK handling import clearance |
| DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) | Everything — parts land at your dock, duty-paid | Nothing further | First-time importers, smaller orders |
For the same part, the quotes look very different:
When comparing quotes across suppliers, normalize the Incoterms. A "cheaper" EXW quote from one supplier loses its edge once duties and freight are added, vs a DDP quote from another.
Two CNC suppliers quote the same 500-unit aluminum bracket order. Which is cheaper?
| Line | Supplier A (US shop) | Supplier B (fobproto) |
|---|---|---|
| Unit price @ 500 | $42.00 | $24.00 |
| Setup/NRE | Included | $220 one-time |
| Tooling/fixture | Included | $350 one-time |
| Material | 6061-T6, US mill | 6061-T6, certified |
| Finish | Clear anodize included | Clear anodize +$2.50 each |
| Inspection | Standard, no FAI | FAI included |
| Lead time | 14 business days | 18 business days + 5 shipping |
| Incoterm | FOB US factory (local freight ~$80) | DDP your US dock |
| Subtotal | $42 × 500 + $80 = $21,080 | $24 × 500 + $2.50 × 500 + $570 + $0 = $13,820 |
Apples to apples: Supplier B (fobproto) costs $7,260 less on this 500-unit order. The FOB-vs-DDP difference alone was $7,000+ because Supplier A looked cheaper per-unit but left out freight and finishing, while Supplier B bundled both.
Email [email protected] with your drawing and a competing quote (redacted if you like). We'll show you a line-by-line comparison — if we're more expensive on apples-to-apples terms, we'll tell you.
Start a quote →